Toaster Oven Liner – Compatible with Breville review

?Have you ever wished cleaning your toaster oven or air fryer was as simple as lifting out a liner and wiping it clean?

First Impressions

I unboxed the Toaster Oven Liner – Compatible with Breville, Cuisinart, Black & Decker, Dash, and More – Nonstick Heat Resistant Reusable Air Fryer Liners, PFOA & BPA Free, 9×11″, 2 Pack, Black and immediately liked how flexible and substantial the liners felt. They don’t feel flimsy like thin foil or low-quality mats; the material has some weight and a textured finish that gave me confidence before I even tried them in my appliances.

Packaging and What’s in the Box

The product arrived as a simple 2-pack of 9×11-inch liners, each neatly folded and labeled so I knew which side faced up. I appreciated the minimal packaging—there was no excess plastic or complicated folding—and the liners came with a small instruction sheet recommending trimming to fit and temperature limits.

Design and Materials

I pay attention to materials when something goes in direct contact with food, and these liners are made from double-sided nonstick PTFE-coated fiberglass. That construction feels solid and explains the heat tolerance claims; the fiberglass base gives structure while the PTFE coating provides the nonstick surface I want for quick cleanup.

Nonstick Coating and Heat Resistance

The liners are rated to withstand temperatures up to 500°F, which matches my typical baking and high-heat roasting needs. In practice they worked fine for broiling chicken wings and reheating pizza slices; I never noticed smoke or warping, and food slid off easily when the liner was cool enough to handle.

Size and Fit

Each liner is 9×11 inches out of the package, and I liked that they’re designed to be trimmed for a custom fit. That made them useful in a variety of devices I own, from a compact air fryer to a mid-sized toaster oven. The rounded corners they mentioned aren’t just a marketing detail — they’re safer to handle and cut than sharp-cornered mats.

Performance in Real-World Use

I tested these liners across multiple cooking tasks over several weeks to see whether they fulfilled the “nonstick” promise and stood up to high temperatures. They made cleanup genuinely easier: when using them under crumb-heavy tasks like baking garlic bread, I could slide them out, shake out crumbs, and wipe away grease without scrubbing the oven bottom.

Baking and Roasting

When I used them for roasting vegetables and baking small pastry items, they prevented bottoming grease and cheese from sticking to the appliance. They didn’t impart any flavor, and the nonstick surface kept fragile items like roasted tomatoes from tearing when I lifted them off.

Air Frying and Toasting

I also used a liner in my air fryer basket and under a wire rack in my toaster oven. They worked well at catching drips and crumbs while letting hot air circulate. For air frying, I trimmed a liner to sit beneath the basket but still leave enough open space for airflow; the results were the same crispy texture without the mess on the oven floor.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning was simple: I let the liner cool slightly, wiped off loose crumbs, and rinsed with soapy water. For tougher grease, a gentle scrub with a nonabrasive sponge did the trick. They’re stated as dishwasher-safe, and I ran one through the top rack a couple of times with no visible degradation.

Compatibility with Appliances

The product description lists compatibility with popular brands like Breville, Cuisinart, Black & Decker, Dash, and more, and I found that to be accurate as long as you measure first. Because the liners are designed to be trimmed, they’re flexible enough for a wide range of models — but measuring the interior dimensions of your appliance before trimming is important to avoid blocking vents or heating elements.

Listed Models and Fit Advice

They specifically mention Breville models TOA-60 and TOA-65, along with Cuisinart and common air fryers like Cosori and Dash. I tried the liner in a Breville toaster oven and a compact Dash air fryer; in both cases, trimming was straightforward and the fit was secure and safe. I recommend cutting a little at a time and testing the fit to avoid accidentally making the liner too small.

Safety and Durability

Safety is a priority for me when nonstick coatings and high heat are involved. These liners claim to be PFOA and BPA free, which eased my concerns about harmful chemicals. I also kept an eye on the liner edges and the coating after repeated high-heat sessions; there was no flaking or peeling visible after a few weeks of heavy use.

High-Heat Use

Because the liners are rated to 500°F, I felt comfortable using them for broiling and high-heat roasting for short intervals. I avoided placing them directly over exposed heating elements and followed the guidance to keep them flat and centered to prevent any contact with wires or extreme localized heat.

Food Safety (PFOA & BPA Free)

I appreciated the PFOA- and BPA-free labeling. That helped me trust that the nonstick coating wouldn’t leach inappropriate chemicals into my food during normal use. Of course I still avoid using metal utensils or abrasive cleaners, since those can damage any PTFE-coated surface over time.

Environmental and Economic Benefits

I’ve been trying to reduce single-use items in my kitchen, and switching from disposable foil or parchment for routine toaster oven use has been a small but meaningful change. These reusable liners remove the need to throw away sheets of foil after every messy roast, and because they’re dishwasher-safe and durable, they cut down on the frequency of buying replacements.

Pros and Cons

I like to weigh strengths and weaknesses before a final recommendation. Below are the main advantages I experienced and a few limitations I noticed in day-to-day use.

Pros:

• Reusable and reduces disposable waste.
• Fits many appliances after trimming.
• Withstands temperatures up to 500°F.
• Nonstick surface makes cleanup quick.
• PFOA & BPA free.

Cons:

• 9×11 size requires trimming for many ovens.
• Not suitable for direct contact with heating coils or flames.
• Will eventually show wear if scrubbed with abrasive tools.

Product Feature Breakdown

I created a clear table to summarize the product’s key specs and my notes so you can compare quickly. This is the easiest way I found to identify whether these liners match your needs.

Feature	Manufacturer Claim	My Notes
Size	9 x 11 inches (per liner)	Easy to trim; fits small to medium ovens after adjustment.
Pack	2 pack	Good value for having a spare while one is in the wash.
Material	PTFE-coated fiberglass	Durable and heat-resistant; nonstick surface performs well.
Max Temp	500°F	Worked well for baking, roasting, and short broiling sessions.
Safety	PFOA & BPA free	Reassuring for food contact at high temps.
Care	Reusable, dishwasher safe	Cleans easily; avoid abrasive cleaners for longevity.
Compatibility	Breville, Cuisinart, Black & Decker, Dash, Cosori, etc.	Trim-to-fit approach makes them versatile across brands.
Corners	Rounded	Easier and safer to trim and handle.
Color	Black	Neutral and hides stains well; aesthetics aren’t flashy.

How I Used the Liners: A Step-by-Step Guide

I like sharing the exact steps I took when testing products so you can follow if you want similar results. Below are the steps I used to trim, fit, and clean the liners without risk.

1. Measured the inside bottom of my toaster oven and air fryer to determine how much trimming was needed. I measured twice to be safe.
2. Placed the liner on top of the appliance bottom to mark where to trim, keeping vents and heating elements in mind so airflow wasn’t blocked. I left small gaps around the edges for air circulation.
3. Trimmed slowly with kitchen scissors, cutting a little at a time and checking fit frequently to prevent removing too much material. I rounded the corners slightly to match the appliance interior.
4. Tested the fit without heat first, then ran the appliance empty at a moderate temperature for a few minutes to ensure no curling or smoke appeared.
5. After using the appliance for cooking, I allowed the liner to cool before removing and wiping off grease or crumbs. For stubborn spots, I soaked the liner briefly in warm soapy water and wiped gently with a nonabrasive sponge.
6. Occasionally placed a liner in the top rack of the dishwasher, which worked well for light cleanup but I reserved that for less greasy runs to avoid buildup in the dishwasher filter.

Tips for Best Results

I learned some practical tips during my testing that helped the liners perform better and last longer. I kept these habits consistently and they made maintenance simple.

• Always measure before trimming and cut in small increments. It’s easier to trim more than to attach back material.
• Never allow the liner to touch exposed heating coils or open flames; use it on flat bottoms or under racks.
• Avoid using metal utensils directly on the liner to reduce risk of scratching the PTFE coating.
• Let the liner cool before cleaning to avoid warping and to make grease removal easier.
• Rotate between the two liners in the pack so one is always available while the other is washing and drying.

Cleaning Methods I Tried

I experimented with multiple cleaning approaches to find what was most effective while preserving the coating. Each method worked as long as I avoided harsh abrasives.

• Hand wash with mild dish soap and a soft sponge: best for removing greasy residue without risking the coating.
• Dishwasher (top rack): convenient for light soiling, though I prefer hand washing for heavy grease.
• Soak with warm water and a little baking soda: useful for odor control and loosening baked-on bits.
• Nonabrasive scrubbing pad for stuck-on bits: used sparingly and only for resilient spots.

Longevity and Wear

After a month of frequent use across different appliances, I didn’t notice significant wear on either liner. The coating showed no peeling and the fiberglass backing stayed intact. Based on my use pattern, I expect a useful lifespan of many months to over a year depending on how aggressively the liners are cleaned and how often they’re used at high heat.

What I Would Improve

No product is perfect, and I think there are small refinements that could make these liners even better. A slightly larger pre-cut size or a few size options in the original kit would be nice for people with larger ovens. Also, including a simple template or perforated guide for common appliance sizes would save time for buyers who are uncertain about measuring and trimming.

Who These Liners Are Best For

I believe these liners suit a range of users from busy cooks who want faster cleanup to people trying to reduce disposables in the kitchen. They’re particularly helpful if you:

• Frequently use a toaster oven for small meals and want to avoid messy cleanups.
• Have an air fryer and want to catch oils and crumbs without blocking airflow.
• Prefer a reusable option instead of foil or parchment.
• Use their toaster oven intermittently and want something easy to remove and wash.

Who Might Want Something Else

There are scenarios where these liners may not be the ideal choice. If you routinely bake at temperatures above 500°F or use open flames, these liners aren’t suited for that extreme environment. Also, folks who want a perfect, non-trim fit for a specific large appliance might prefer buying a liner sized specifically for that model rather than cutting to fit.

Frequently Asked Questions (and My Answers)

I gathered the most common questions people ask about these liners and answered them from my testing experience.

Q: Can I use these liners for broiling? A: Yes, but with caution. They handle up to 500°F and can tolerate short broiling sessions, but avoid direct contact with heating elements and monitor closely to prevent scorching.

Q: Will the coating flake off into my food? A: In my tests I didn’t see any flaking. I recommend avoiding metal utensils and abrasive cleaners so the PTFE coating remains intact.

Q: Can I use them on a grill? A: They’re not designed for direct flame or open-coil grilling. They work best inside ovens and air fryers or under a rack where the heat is more controlled.

Q: How often should I replace them? A: That depends on use frequency. With proper care, I expect months to over a year of use. Replace them when you observe significant wear, deep scratches, or coating separation.

How They Compare to Alternatives

I often compare products to common alternatives so you can decide what’s right for your routine.

• Versus disposable foil: These liners save money and waste over time, and the nonstick surface prevents tearing and sticking the way foil sometimes does.
• Versus parchment paper: Parchment can be convenient but is single-use and doesn’t offer the same durability for trapped grease; these liners last through many uses.
• Versus silicone baking mats: Silicone mats work well for baking sheets but often aren’t designed for the odd shapes and heat-flow concerns of toaster ovens and air fryers. The fiberglass/PTFE combination here handles higher heat and is thinner, making it easier to trim for custom fits.

Personal Anecdote from My Kitchen

I used a liner during a weekend pizza session where my kids added extra cheese and toppings that inevitably melted and dripped. Instead of having to scrape hardened cheese off the oven floor, I lifted the liner, shook off crumbs, and wiped the grease away. That simple step saved me nearly 20 minutes of scrubbing and left the oven smelling neutral instead of smoky.

Final Verdict

I recommend the Toaster Oven Liner – Compatible with Breville, Cuisinart, Black & Decker, Dash, and More – Nonstick Heat Resistant Reusable Air Fryer Liners, PFOA & BPA Free, 9×11″, 2 Pack, Black for anyone who uses a toaster oven or air fryer regularly and wants an easy, reusable solution for messy cooking. They’re versatile, durable, and effective—and with basic care, they can reduce waste and save time on cleanup.

If you want, I can help you decide whether the 9×11 size will fit your specific appliance model or guide you step-by-step through trimming one to fit safely.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.