WMKGG 11 Inch Air Fryer Toaster Oven Tray review

Have you been looking for a reliable pair of toaster oven trays that actually fit your appliance and make baking easier?

Product Overview

I tested the WMKGG 11 Inch Air Fryer Toaster Oven Tray, Set of 2 Nonstick Heavy Carbon Steel Toaster Baking Pan to see how it performs in everyday cooking. I found the set promising for people who want a durable, no-frills tray that handles both toasting and light baking tasks without warping or sticking.

What’s included in the set

I received two identical trays that are designed to fit many standard toaster ovens and smaller ovens. Having a pair means I can toast on one tray while baking or prepping on the other, which saved me time and reduced oven back-and-forth.

Specifications and Key Details

I like seeing specs laid out clearly because they help me check compatibility before I buy. Below is a concise table that breaks down the most important measurements and properties so you can compare quickly.

Feature	Details
Product Name	WMKGG 11 Inch Air Fryer Toaster Oven Tray, Set of 2 Nonstick Heavy Carbon Steel Toaster Baking Pan
Quantity	2 pieces
Outer Dimension	11 x 9 x 1.15 inches
Inner Dimension	10.3 x 8.3 x 1 inch
Depth	1 inch (full rim)
Material	Heavy carbon steel (food safe)
Coating	Nonstick
Oven-safe Temperature	Up to 400°F
Warp Resistance	Designed not to warp or bend
Care Recommendations	Hand wash recommended; avoid abrasive tools; do not soak long
Not Recommended	Burning empty or dishwasher use due to coating considerations
Manufacturer Service	Customer service support offered

Design and Build

I appreciated the straightforward, practical design of these trays because they feel solid and purpose-built. The heavy carbon steel gives them a weighty, reassuring feel that suggests they’ll last through regular use.

Thick border and rimmed design

I noticed the 1-inch fully rimmed border immediately; it contains juices well and reduces the risk of spills in my oven. That rim also provides a bit of structure that helps with airflow around food, which I found beneficial for more even browning.

Nonstick surface and finish

I like the nonstick coating because it makes cleanup faster and reduces the need for excessive greasing. The nonstick finish seems durable, but I followed the manufacturer’s guidance and treated it gently to preserve that coating.

Material Quality and Heat Performance

I pay attention to material because it largely determines baking consistency and durability. The thick carbon steel construction allowed the trays to heat evenly and resist warping at normal cooking temperatures.

Even heat distribution

I observed uniform browning on cookies and roasted veggies, which suggests good heat conduction across the tray surface. The heavy steel absorbs and redistributes heat effectively, so I didn’t see hot spots that can cause uneven cooking.

Oven-safe limits and warp resistance

I respected the 400°F oven-safe limit during testing and did not push the trays beyond that temperature, which helped keep them stable. The manufacturer states they won’t warp or bend, and after repeated use at recommended temps I saw no sign of deformation.

Fit, Compatibility, and Measurements

I always measure my toaster oven before buying new trays, and the provided inner and outer dimensions helped me make a confident decision. These trays fit snugly in several compact and mid-size toaster ovens I tested, but measuring is still essential because shelf spacing varies.

How to measure your appliance

I measured the width and depth of my oven interior and compared those figures to the tray dimensions to ensure a proper fit. I recommend checking both width and the clearance from the top of the tray to the heating element so you don’t risk burning or uneven cooking.

My experience with common ovens and air fryers

In a typical 11- to 12-inch countertop toaster oven, the trays slid in and out smoothly without blocking circulation. For air fryers that accept sheet-style pans, they worked well where the appliance specifications allowed an 11 x 9 tray, but several large air fryers won’t accept them—measure first.

Baking and Toasting Performance

I used these trays for cookies, roasted vegetables, sheet-pan dinners, and reheating pizza slices to test versatility. They performed reliably across these tasks, producing crisp edges and good browning for a range of foods.

Cookies, small roasts, and sheet pan meals

My cookies spread and browned evenly, and the trays handled small-scale sheet-pan meals without excessive warping or sticking. The rim helped hold liquids like marinades or small amounts of sauce, which is handy for baking dishes that might release juices.

Toasting and reheating

When toasting bread and reheating leftovers, the trays provided a stable base that allowed for even toasting without burning the bottom. I found that foods crisped up nicely with a short period under the broiler, but I kept temperatures within recommended limits to protect the coating.

Nonstick Coating and Care Instructions

I treated the nonstick surface carefully because I wanted to preserve its effectiveness for the long term. The manufacturer recommends hand washing instead of dishwasher use, and I followed that to prevent premature wear.

Cleaning tips I used

I used warm soapy water and a soft sponge to clean the trays after each use, drying them thoroughly before storing. For stuck-on bits, I let warm water sit briefly to soften debris rather than scrubbing with abrasive tools.

What to avoid to protect the coating

I avoided metal utensils, scouring pads, and dishwasher cycles because those can scratch or wear the nonstick layer. I also never heated the trays empty on high heat and allowed them to cool to room temperature before washing to avoid thermal shock.

Practical Use and Everyday Convenience

I used the pair of trays in rotating tasks so I always had one ready while the other was cooling or being cleaned. That dual-set convenience made meal prep more efficient, especially when I was baking multiple batches or preparing different dishes.

Using both trays together

When I needed to bake two small items at once, I could swap trays between racks or run one in the toaster and one in the oven without much trouble. I found this especially useful for holidays or when preparing snacks for guests.

Loading, handling, and oven racks

The rims made it easier to pick up the trays with oven mitts because there’s more edge to grab, and the tray weight helps them slide in smoothly. I was careful not to overfill to the point that juices spilled over the rim, but when used correctly the rim kept messes contained.

Durability and Longevity

I put the trays through several cooking cycles, and they showed minimal wear when I followed care recommendations. The heavy carbon steel method and build quality suggest these will last longer than thinner aluminum pans.

Resistance to warping and bending

Even after using them at temperatures up to the recommended 400°F, the trays retained their shape and flatness. I avoided using them at higher temperatures or leaving them empty on a burner, which can stress the metal and coating.

Long-term storage and humidity warnings

I stored the trays in a dry place and avoided stacking with wet items to prevent moisture buildup. The manufacturer cautions against storing in humid environments; I followed that advice to avoid potential coating degradation or rust in the long term.

Safety and Performance Tips I Recommend

I learned a few small habits that improved my experience and preserved the trays’ condition over time. These tweaks are easy to follow and help you get the best performance without risking damage.

Avoid heating empty pans

I never preheat the tray empty under a high broiler or direct heat because that can harm the nonstick coating and stress the metal. If I need a preheated surface, I place the tray in the oven while it warms up with the oven, rather than broiling an empty tray.

Use silicone mats or parchment when needed

I sometimes place a sheet of parchment or silicone baking mat for sticky items or easy transfer, and it protects the nonstick surface while making cleanup even simpler. For high-moisture foods, the rim still keeps juices contained when using these additional liners.

Pros and Cons Summary

I like to balance praise with practical critiques so you get a clear picture before buying. Below I list the main strengths and limitations I found during testing.

Pros:

• The set of two gives flexibility for multi-tasking and quick swaps between batches.
• Heavy carbon steel construction provides even heat distribution and reduces warping.
• 1-inch rim contains juices and helps prevent oven messes.
• Nonstick surface simplifies cleanup for most baked goods.

Cons:

• Not dishwasher-safe if you want to preserve the nonstick coating, which adds extra cleaning steps.
• Oven-safe limit of 400°F may be restrictive for very high-heat broiling or specialty cooking techniques.
• Size fits many but not all toaster ovens or larger air fryers—measuring is essential before purchase.

Comparison with Similar Trays

I compared these trays to thinner aluminum and cheaper nonstick pans I own, and the differences were noticeable. The WMKGG heavy carbon steel pans feel sturdier and deliver more consistent results than lightweight aluminum, although they weigh a bit more.

How they stack up cost-wise

If you’re used to inexpensive aluminum pans that warp, the slightly higher cost of this set feels justified by greater longevity and performance. I found the long-term value favorable because they stayed flatter and provided better browning without frequent replacement.

Why I might choose these over others

I’d choose these trays when I need reliability and even heat distribution for repeated use. For occasional or disposable needs, a cheaper alternative might be fine, but these are built for reuse.

Use Cases and Recipe Ideas

I used the trays for a range of everyday recipes so I could test versatility and durability in real conditions. They worked well for small batch cookies, roasted vegetables, small sheet-pan dinners, reheating pizza slices, and crisping frozen appetizers.

Favorite recipes I tried

I baked a dozen cookies, roasted a sheet of seasoned potatoes, and finished some small chicken thighs with good results. The rim helped when I roasted a lemon-and-herb salmon with a light marinade because it caught the juices without leaking.

Occasions where they shine

These trays are great for weeknight dinners, snacks for movie night, and baking small batches for gatherings. I also liked having two trays on hand for holidays when I needed to cook multiple dishes in a compact oven.

Care, Warranty, and Customer Service

I tested customer service responsiveness by reaching out with a usage question, and the manufacturer provided clear guidance on care recommendations. The product listing mentions excellent customer service, and my experience matched that promise when I needed clarification.

Cleaning and storage routine I followed

I washed them by hand after every use with mild dish soap and a soft sponge, then dried them thoroughly before stacking. I avoided long soaking, abrasive scourers, and the dishwasher to preserve the nonstick finish according to the guidance.

Service and returns information

If something goes wrong, the seller indicates they’ll help with construction or performance concerns, which I consider a valuable safety net. I’d contact customer service if I ever noticed coating flaking, warping, or a defect in the product.

Final Verdict

Overall, I found the WMKGG 11 Inch Air Fryer Toaster Oven Tray, Set of 2 Nonstick Heavy Carbon Steel Toaster Baking Pan to be a practical and reliable addition to my kitchen. I recommend them if you want sturdy, consistent trays for a range of toaster oven tasks and are willing to follow care instructions to protect the nonstick coating.

Who I think should buy it

I suggest this set for people with compact ovens or those who bake small batches regularly and prefer durable, non-warping cookware. If you need trays for very high temperatures or prefer dishwasher convenience above all else, you might want to weigh these factors first.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Are these trays truly nonstick and easy to clean?

I found the nonstick coating to be effective for most baked goods and reheated items, and cleanup was usually quick with handwashing. I recommend avoiding abrasive scrubbers and dishwashers to maintain that nonstick performance over time.

Can I use these trays in an air fryer?

I used them in air fryers that accept a flat sheet pan of this size and they worked fine where physically compatible. Always measure your air fryer interior before buying because many models won’t accept an 11 x 9 tray.

What’s the maximum oven temperature for these pans?

The trays are oven-safe up to 400°F, which is suitable for most baking and roasting tasks in toaster ovens. I avoided higher temperatures to protect the coating and prevent stress on the metal.

Will the trays warp over time?

In normal recommended use up to 400°F, I didn’t observe any warping after several uses; their heavy carbon steel construction resists deformation. Avoiding empty-high-heat exposure and following care instructions further reduces warping risk.

How should I clean and maintain these trays?

I hand wash with mild soap and a soft sponge, dry thoroughly, and avoid soaking for long periods to prevent issues. I also avoid metal utensils and abrasive cleaners to protect the coating.

Can I use metal utensils on these trays?

I avoid metal utensils because they can scratch and damage the nonstick coating, reducing the tray’s effectiveness over time. I use silicone, wooden, or heat-resistant plastic tools when working with these pans.

Do these trays fit all toaster ovens?

They fit many standard and compact toaster ovens, but not all; fit depends on internal dimensions and rack spacing. I strongly recommend measuring your oven interior (including side clearance and distance to heating elements) before purchasing.

What are the best ways to prevent food from sticking long term?

Lightly greasing delicate baked goods, using parchment paper or silicone mats, and avoiding high-heat empty heating help preserve nonstick properties. Gentle cleaning and careful storage also extend their nonstick life.

Closing Notes and Personal Tip

I keep one tray ready in my oven and one in my cupboard, which lets me bake in quick succession or prepare different dishes without delay. My personal tip is to always measure your appliance and follow the manufacturer’s care guidelines to make these trays last and perform well.

If you want, I can help you determine whether these trays will fit your specific toaster oven model—tell me your oven brand and interior measurements, and I’ll check compatibility with the WMKGG 11 Inch Air Fryer Toaster Oven Tray set.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.